An Analysis of Two Types of Reverse Mortgages

Blog Post Image

Home Equity Conversion Mortgage (HECM)

Features: HECM is the most common type of reverse mortgage, insured by the Federal Housing Administration (FHA). It offers several key features:

a. FHA Insurance: HECM loans are backed by FHA insurance, providing borrowers with additional protection and ensuring that the loan balance will never exceed the home's value when repaid.

b. Loan Limits: The amount a homeowner can borrow through an HECM is subject to FHA's lending limits, which vary based on the property's location and other factors.

c. Payout Options: HECM borrowers can choose from various payout options, including a lump sum, monthly payments, a line of credit, or a combination of these.

Benefits: HECM reverse mortgages offer several advantages:

a. Government-Backed Security: FHA insurance provides peace of mind to borrowers and their heirs, knowing that they won't be held liable for any loan amount exceeding the home's value.

b. Regulated and Transparent: HECM loans are highly regulated, ensuring fair terms and transparency in the lending process.

c. Flexible Payout Options: Borrowers can tailor the payout to their specific financial needs, whether they prefer regular monthly payments or a line of credit for future use.

Proprietary Reverse Mortgages

Features: Proprietary reverse mortgages, also known as Jumbo reverse mortgages, are private loans offered by financial institutions. Unlike HECMs, which are government-backed, proprietary reverse mortgages are not insured by the FHA.

a. Higher Loan Limits: Proprietary reverse mortgages typically have higher lending limits than HECMs, allowing homeowners with more valuable properties to access a larger portion of their equity.

b. Credit and Income Requirements: Because proprietary reverse mortgages are not government-insured, lenders may assess the borrower's creditworthiness and income to determine eligibility.

c. More Flexibility: Financial institutions offering proprietary reverse mortgages have more leeway in setting the terms and conditions, allowing for increased flexibility in loan structures.

Benefits: Proprietary reverse mortgages offer unique benefits:

a. Higher Loan Amounts: Homeowners with significant home equity can access more funds compared to HECMs, making it an attractive option for those with high-value properties.

b. Private Lending Process: The proprietary reverse mortgage process is more private, which some borrowers may prefer over the more regulated HECM process.

c. Competitive Rates: Some proprietary reverse mortgages may offer competitive interest rates and fees, making it a viable alternative to HECMs for certain borrowers.

Comparative Analysis

1. Eligibility and Loan Limits: Both HECMs and proprietary reverse mortgages have age requirements (62 years or older) for borrowers. However, proprietary reverse mortgages may have additional eligibility criteria, such as credit and income assessments. HECMs have standardized loan limits set by the FHA, whereas proprietary reverse mortgages may provide higher loan limits, making them suitable for homeowners with substantial home equity.

2. Insurance and Protection: One of the key distinctions between HECMs and proprietary reverse mortgages is FHA insurance. HECMs are government-backed, providing borrowers with added protection against the loan balance exceeding the home's value. Proprietary reverse mortgages lack this FHA insurance, which means borrowers may not have the same level of protection in the event of a downturn in the housing market.

3. Payout Options and Flexibility: Both types of reverse mortgages offer various payout options, including lump sums, lines of credit, and monthly payments. HECMs and proprietary reverse mortgages provide flexibility in how borrowers receive their funds, catering to individual financial needs.

4. Regulation and Transparency: HECMs are highly regulated by the government, providing borrowers with transparency and standardized terms. On the other hand, proprietary reverse mortgages are offered by private financial institutions, potentially offering more personalized terms but with varying degrees of transparency.

5. Interest Rates and Fees: Interest rates and fees for both HECMs and proprietary reverse mortgages can vary between lenders. Borrowers should compare and evaluate the rates and fees associated with each type of loan to make an informed decision.

6. Loan Repayment: Both types of reverse mortgages become due when the last borrower leaves the home permanently or passes away. The home is typically sold to repay the loan, and any remaining equity belongs to the borrower or their heirs.

When choosing between an HECM and a proprietary reverse mortgage, it's essential to consider your unique financial situation, home value, and specific needs. HECMs provide government-backed security and are suitable for borrowers seeking standardized and regulated loan terms. Proprietary reverse mortgages, with their potentially higher loan limits and increased flexibility, may be more appealing to homeowners with valuable properties and more complex financial goals.

Back to Blog